pilgrim cupcakes

How to Make Pilgrim Cupcakes for Thanksgiving

, ,

Are you looking for Thanksgiving cupcakes ideas? Make these pilgrim cupcakes for kids while they learn about the history of Thanksgiving.

The kids have been learning about the Pilgrims at school and the history of Thanksgiving at school.

I made these pilgrim cupcakes and the kids at school made paper bag costumes to wear for this unit.

pilgrim cupcakes
Pilgrim cupcakes made for a unit study at school.

Pilgrim cupcakes

Supplies

  • Plain vanilla cupcakes in brown cupcake liners
  • White icing
  • Cocoa powder
  • Chocolate for melting (perfect excuse to use up some of that Halloween candy)
  • Large marshmallows
  • Chocolate coated cookies
  • Wilton Sparkle Gel – white, yellow, and black
  • Large round Wilton tip with a piping bag and tape.
  • Toothpicks (or any other kind of pick or narrow skewer)

Instructions

Begin by making the Pilgrim hat.  Melt the chocolate in the microwave and using a pick coat each marshmallow in melted chocolate.  Place it carefully on top of the cookie and pop it in the refrigerator until set.  Once set gently remove the pick. Using the sparkle gel add on a white band and yellow buckle, then set aside.

A collage of photos to show how to make pilgrim cupcakes.
Step-by-step instructions to make Pilgrim cupcakes.

Mix a small amount of cocoa at a time with plain white icing until you get a color you are happy with.   Place the tip inside the bag (cut off the end of the bag) and tape the bag onto the tip.  Fill the bag with icing and holding your hand very steady and keeping the tip just above the top of the cupcake pipe a face onto each cupcake.  If you push down just a little while piping you will see that the icing fills out so it covers more of the top of the cupcake.

Place the hat on top of the icing and using the black sparkle gel add facial features.

Tonya Staab
About the author
Tonya Staab
Head Start Teacher. Lifestyle Blogger. Content Creator. Author. Photographer. Memory Maker. Mum.

32 thoughts on “How to Make Pilgrim Cupcakes for Thanksgiving”

  1. I just saw this today & these are the best Thanksgiving cupcakes ever! What kind of vanilla frosting did you use? It doesn’t look completely white..

    Reply

Leave a Comment