Non-Candy Halloween Treats for Boo Bags

by Tonya Staab
Published: Updated:

Surprise your neighbors with boo bags this Halloween. We have lots of boo bag ideas including non-candy Halloween treats.

We all love a good treat, especially over Halloween, but do we really need so much candy? Between trick-or-treating, class gifts, parties, and special treats it can become very easy to over-indulge.

Boo bag ideas

Monster eyeball boo bag ideas
Non-candy boo bag ideas everyone will love.

I created the above monster eyeball goodie bag a few years ago. It doesn’t contain candy but does contain a few items such as edible eyes and food writing pens so that families can create their own allergy-friendly treats. You can get all my instructions at The Centsible Life including free printables.

Here’s a great list of non-candy Halloween treats that kids will love just as much and get far more use out. These alternatives are the perfect Halloween goodie bag ideas to hand out to school friends and parties too.

Coloring pages and crayons

Print out Halloween-themed coloring pages, roll them up with twine and attach a small box of crayons.

Tie boxes of crayons with coloring pages for non candy Halloween treats
Halloween coloring pages tied with boxes of crayons.

Better yet, melt broken crayons in the oven, pour them into Halloween candy molds, and put them into the freezer to set.

I have made crayons from the kid’s broken crayon pieces before, but I decided to try something a little different this time around.

Halloween themed crayons made at home using a candy mold
Homemade Halloween crayons made using a candy mold.


  • Broken pieces of crayon
  • Silican muffin pans
  • Candy molds


  1. Preheat the oven to 250F.
  2. Put the broken pieces of cryaon into the muffin pans (break larger pieces in half).
  3. Put the muffin pan into the oven for about 20-minutes. Note, the muffin pans in the center of the tray will take longer to melt than the ones around the outside.
  4. The crayons turn into liquid (it’s okay if there are a few small chunks too).
  5. Very carefully (because it’s very hot) pour the liquid into candy or ice-cube molds.
  6. Place the molds into the freezer until the crayons are hard, and then remove from the mold.

Multi-packs of Play-Doh are everywhere right now. Pop one into a bag with a Halloween-themed cookie cutter, or cookie stamp. Kids will love making their own Play-Doh creations.

play dough and cookie cutter halloween goodie bag ideas for kids
Play-Doh and cookie-cutter non-candy Halloween treat bags for kids.


  • Medium-sized (4.75″ x 6.75″) transparent archival bag
  • Card stock
  • Play-Doh tub
  • Cookie cutter
  • Stapler


  1. Put a cookie cutter and small tub of Play-Doh into the bag.
  2. Either make or have the kids decorate a card to attach to the top.
  3. Fold the card over the top of the bag and staple it in place so that the goodies inside don’t fall out.

Temporary tattoos

Kids love tattoos. You can put them into Halloween bags, boo bags, or set up at ‘tattoo station’ at your front door for trick-or-treaters. Have a sponge and water ready to apply the temporary tattoos.

Glow sticks

Glow sticks, bracelets, and necklaces are a big hit, especially if kids can wear them as they trick-or-treat!

Halloween slime

hotel transylvania slime
Hotel Transylvania homemade slime in fun containers for kids.

What kid doesn’t love slime? Make your own, or buy multi-packs of mini slime containers. I have instructions to make these Hotel Transylvania slime containers at Lady and the Blog and glow-in-the-dark slime at Kids Activities Blog.

Halloween popcorn bags

Halloween popcorn mix
Halloween popcorn mix with white chocolate spiderwebs and candy spiders.

Mini popcorn bags are the perfect snack for kids to enjoy once they get home and are settled in front of a Halloween movie. Put popcorn into clear treat bags, tie the top, and then turn it over and use a permanent marker to draw on ghost features. We have a yummy Halloween popcorn mix idea if you are looking for ideas.

Halloween juice boxes

Wrap colored paper around mini juice boxes to turn them into ghosts, pumpkins, Frankenstein, and other fun Halloween characters. Draw on fun faces with a Sharpie. Put fun Halloween stickers over the labels of water bottles saying things such as ‘witches brew’, or ‘poison’. Kids will enjoy having a drink while trick-or-treating, or while enjoying some of their other Halloween treats.

Fruit leather mummies

Wrap packets of fruit leather up in bandages, and draw on eyes to make fruit leather mummies.

Jack O’Lantern oranges

My kids are absolutely loving oranges right now. Draw a fun Jack-O-Lantern face on them and place them in a big fruit basket or cauldron to hand out. You can see how these look on my Halloween school lunch post.

Non-candy Halloween treats

Items such as squishy eyeballs, stretchy mice, spiders, fake fingers, glow-in-the-dark bats, and vampire’s teeth are sure to have kids squealing in delight. 

Do have any other ideas for candy-free Halloween treats?  Leave them in the comments to build upon this list.

Please pin this post for later:

boo bags Pinterest image

You Might Also Like These Too


mom taxi julie October 12, 2010 - 5:18 pm

You’re so awesome 🙂

Melanie October 12, 2010 - 11:06 pm

Boy o boy do we have broken pieces of crayons. I love these and I know the kids would too! I am going to keep my eye out for candy molds.

Anne@LittleSproutBooks October 13, 2010 - 10:37 pm

Just got some cutie candy molds at the dollar store – now I have a project to go with them! Yay!

Jody October 14, 2010 - 2:49 pm

Great idea! I know what to do with my pumpkin molds now!Thanks for sharing!

Tonya Staab October 15, 2010 - 3:06 pm

ha ha, so happy I could add something else to your 'to do' list. 

Tonya Staab October 15, 2010 - 3:08 pm

ooh, pumpkin molds, what a great idea.  I'm picturing lots of melted orange crayons and a dropper of black or brown melted crayon to add color to the stalk … I wonder if that would work.  Now you have me wanting to try again :).

Burgh Baby October 15, 2010 - 11:44 am

ARGH! Darn you for the (good) idea that now I HAVE to do! 😉

jackie October 15, 2010 - 5:34 pm

great idea!

Tonya Staab October 16, 2010 - 7:19 pm

Thank you Jackie.

Tonya Staab October 16, 2010 - 8:20 pm

What is it with the 2-4 year old age group that love to snap their crayons in half?  One of those things that baffles me.  Give those gorgeous kids a hug from me.

Tonya Staab October 16, 2010 - 8:47 pm

Yay.  So glad I could help 🙂

Tonya Staab October 29, 2010 - 9:42 am

Love the magnets, great job Ali and thank you so much for the link love.   So glad you made the crayons too, I'll be looking out for the post.

Ali @PickleSugarPlum October 29, 2010 - 7:10 am

I ended up using halloween themed silicone muffin pans, and didn’t need the candy molds…they turned out great! I can’t wait to post them on my blog later today! Thanks for the crafting inspiration, Lovey…I also posted a tutorial for some felt magnets over at, and mentioned your post! Thanks again!


Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More